X/@dom_lucre
The rumor broke and went viral in the media. It stated that Marvel Studios might have considered hiring a white for a Black Panther project yet to be named. The mere tweeting of “ittens” by blogger Dom Lucre had circulated, along with what purportedly was concept art of a Caucasian Black Panther, the legitimacy of which could never be established.
Advertisement
It was an idea that went beyond human imagining for comic buffs and casual viewers alike: the Black Panther turning from black to white. The dispute has been anything but silent, with thousands from both camps chiming in.
One commenter reiterated a sentiment shared by many: “I’m sure all of the people who are defending the casting of Paapa Essiedu as Severus Snape will be here to defend this decision soon, right? Right?” The sarcasm is trying to draw attention to what is seen as a double standard when it comes to ethnic changes of characters in adaptations.
The conversation degenerated when another answered, “LMAO! That’s rich. Said by the race that gets every race swap for the last 20 years. GTFOH! Do I like this idea, if it’s real? Hell NO! Black Panther is a Black hero, and he should stay that way.” This ardent defense of T’Challa’s racial identity as fundamental to the character found resonance with many.
Some would attempt to split hairs about various instances of race-swapping. One wise remark returned with, “Not quite the same as race-swapping T’Challa. Black Panther is a title, not a name.” The technicality was barely enough to quell the storm, however, as others pointed to occasions with white characters changed by race without such outrage.
This discussion then expanded into more general Hollywood trends. “Kinda like the whole Captain America BS. Marvel sucks anymore,” grumbled one disillusioned observer, while another proceeded into a litany of controversial casting decisions: “Uh, the new Jesus is a black chick with a bull ring. So, yeah this is the first black character that’s been race swapped, and it’s all stupid.”
Many took the rumors as nothing but provocations for stir-up. “Yay, more race baiting to rile up everyone even more,” sighed one entertained observer, with another throwing, “They want us against each other.” These statements speak of cultural fatigue felt by many over what they perceive to be manufactured controversies in entertainment media.
The historical backdrop for Black Panther just gives the fire more fuel. Created in 1966 during Civil Rights, the character was revolutionary in that there were hardly any mainstream Black superheroes at that time. Suggesting a white Panther is too much for any dedicated reader of the comics or other media to stomach since being Wakandan and African is very central to the mythology of the character.
Several tried to set them up in comparison with other recent casting dilemmas. “Remember when they did Hamilton with non Whites and tons of other European history and folklore with blacks,” one commentator remarked, stressing the inconsistent responses to different kinds of racial bending in castings.
Things got into uncomfortable territory when a user implied that the development of African civilization is a fallacy and this begins the dialogues away from West entertainment toward more common spheres of racial tension.
No sightings on behalf of Marvel Studios have been given lately indicating any black Panther recast as white, thereby placing this rumor squarely “in the speculative quarter.” It’s this very intensity that, in essence, builds layers around these sentiments-as-casting decisions that have boxed this issue and become heavily cultural nowadays.
Some of them mocked it. “Haha, woke go broke…how do they like it?” one commenter stipulates before stating, “My, how the tables have turned.” These are really the brief pauses for laughter in a really angry conversation.
This discussion will quickly lead us toward the fundamental questions of representation, authenticity, and creative licenses in adaptations. “They need to leave shit alone. No one want a Black Snape or White Panther,” one user states, a simple assertion right at the heart of this discussion.
Whatever may or may not have been the truth of the rumor, the genuine reaction puts in evidence how much these characters and their representation actually matter to audiences. In this hostile environment wherein every casting is a cultural flashpoint, Marvel must very carefully balance between their creative reinterpretation and sincere reverence for source materials that mean so much to so many people.
Advertisement
This particular controversy will have its moment of calm; the discussion of representation in media will never reach that point. For now, the fans are divided and impassioned, ready to pounce on the slightest provocation to defend their cherished view of these characters.
