Gil Birmingham on Thomas Rainwater’s Path Forward in Yellowstone Season 5

As Yellowstone Season 5 gears up for the explosive continuation, fans are bracing for answers to questions that have been brewing since the show’s inception. 

Amid power struggles, familial loyalty, and fierce devotion to the land, one of the most captivating dynamics remains the evolving relationship between the Dutton family and Thomas Rainwater, the chairman of the Broken Rock Reservation. 

Played by the talented Gil Birmingham, Rainwater is more than just an adversary to John Dutton (Kevin Costner); he’s a man with deep-rooted beliefs, a mission for justice, and a profound respect for the land that stretches far beyond personal gain.

Birmingham, a Comanche actor whose performances have often highlighted themes of indigenous identity and resilience, brings a powerful authenticity to the role of Rainwater.

 Since his character’s introduction in Yellowstone Season 1, Rainwater has stood as both a symbol of the land’s history and a reminder of the injustices that remain unresolved.

While the Duttons fight to protect their family’s legacy, Rainwater sees himself as a protector of a different kind — one whose connection to the land is not about legacy but about survival, heritage, and healing from centuries of historical trauma.

The complexity of Rainwater’s character, coupled with his shared respect for the land with John Dutton, has led to a fascinating push-and-pull between the two men.

They represent two worlds that rarely intersect peacefully, yet both recognize a sacred responsibility to the land. 

“For Rainwater, it’s not just about his connection to the land; it’s about correcting wrongs that go back generations,” Birmingham says. This deep motivation underscores every decision Rainwater makes and every challenge he faces.

As we move into the second half of Yellowstone Season 5, Birmingham hints at escalating tension and monumental decisions that could change the course of the show. 

With John Dutton’s possible exit looming — a twist fans speculate could reshape the power dynamics in Montana — Rainwater’s path is poised for a dramatic evolution. 

For Birmingham, the upcoming episodes provide a chance to delve even deeper into his character’s psyche, exploring how Rainwater might respond if the power vacuum left by John Dutton shifts the control over the land in unexpected ways.

In a recent conversation, Birmingham opened up about Rainwater’s journey, the stakes involved, and the subtle but powerful ways this season’s storytelling could impact his character’s future. 

From the challenges of limited script access to the significance of honoring his people’s heritage, Birmingham’s insights reveal a rich tapestry of motivations that make Rainwater one of Yellowstone’s most intriguing figures.

When asked about how Rainwater would react if John Dutton’s hold over the land were removed, Birmingham notes, “It depends on whose influence the land would be in.” 

If that influence shifted to him, Rainwater would be “happy as a lark.” But, he continues, the show’s storylines are complex, with family dynamics and ancestral ties shaping every decision.

Birmingham explains that this season could bring even tougher decisions, as the Duttons and Rainwater confront their responsibilities and the weight of their heritage. 

“Everybody’s going to be put on the spot to make decisions that are going to affect the land, the ranch, and themselves. Everybody’s going to be affected,” he shares. 

It’s this tension that has long fueled the dynamic between the Duttons and Rainwater, a delicate balance rooted in shared respect for the land.

Since his introduction on Yellowstone, Rainwater has evolved from a fierce, newly appointed tribal chairman into a man walking a fine line between confrontation and collaboration with the Dutton family. 

Birmingham highlights Rainwater’s sense of injustice as a driving force, rooted in understanding his heritage and the history of land confiscation.

When he encountered John Dutton, another fierce protector of the land, the two men clashed but eventually found common ground. 

“It was always about the preservation of the pristine of the land. It’s very sacred for Rainwater, it’s our mother earth. And I think John Dutton felt similarly, even if it was in the context of a family legacy, ” he says, acknowledging that despite differing perspectives, both men view the land as sacred.

Reflecting on filming this season with limited script access, Birmingham found this process familiar for Rainwater, whose scenes often center on larger issues rather than Dutton family drama. 

“It wasn’t really a whole lot different for Rainwater because he doesn’t really get engaged in what the family dynamics are. It’s only as he’s affected by anything that happens on the Dutton Ranch,” he shares. 

This dynamic reinforces Rainwater’s role as an outsider, but one with a powerful mission.

As for Rainwater’s evolution, Birmingham sees his character as on a mission for justice and change — a journey that spans generations. 

“It could take generations to change what’s been embedded within a culture…you can only step forward and do as much as you can,” he reflects, expressing Rainwater’s dedication to upholding treaties and righting historic injustices. 

This deep-rooted drive shapes Rainwater’s path, keeping him grounded in his quest for what’s right.

With Yellowstone keeping fans on their toes, Birmingham’s portrayal of Rainwater continues to stand as a testament to the power of resilience, justice, and respect for heritage. And as Rainwater faces new challenges, the stakes couldn’t be higher.

Yellowstone Season 5 Part 2 premieres on Sunday, November 10 at 8/7c on Paramount Network, with a special encore on CBS two hours later.

Watch Yellowstone Online