Off Campus Could Be the Next TSITP or Heated Rivalry, So Why Is Prime Video Fumbling It?

Let’s say it again for the executives in the back who aren’t getting the message: weekly episodic drops work.

There has been plenty of debate about the binge-drop format versus weekly episodic release, specifically among streamers. The truth is that what works depends on the content and the demo.

But when it comes to the Young Adult genre, especially those trusty book-to-screen adaptations, episodic drops are crucial.

Which is why the strategy for Off Campus is so alarming, even when we’ve witnessed what bears the most successful fruit for these types of series.

We needn’t look any further than the massive success of Heated Rivalry.

It became a global sensation, taking streaming by storm and becoming this cultural juggernaut and touchstone that we haven’t seen since, well, ironically, The Summer I Turned Pretty.

These adaptations aren’t just shows you stumble upon over a random weekend. They’re conversation starters that stay at the forefront before release, throughout their run, and long after the finale.

And that’s because these series break the mold, not just reaching young and new adult audiences but broader demographics. Oh, right, and also they aren’t just something you watch, these shows are something you experience.

In many ways, it’s a nod to how television used to be. The watercooler effect. A shared, collective experience where people come together for one episode and spend the rest of the week unpacking it, dissecting every moment, and eagerly waiting for more.

It’s no surprise that the biggest, buzziest series presently are episodic releases. The Pitt had us in a chokehold, on pins and needles every week, dissecting and theorizing every facet of the show in between episodes.

It sparked think pieces, deep analysis, and constant conversation.

That’s the television experience. It’s an ode to the artistry of the medium, not a race to see who can binge something the fastest.

The most successful series are truly those that are savored rather than just consumed. And no other genre benefits from this more than YA.

A great drama, a talented and attractive cast, and a serviceable script are all it really takes to appeal to younger adults and keep them locked in every week.

But what keeps them invested is the ability to build a fandom, create community, engage in discourse, and feel like they’re part of something unfolding in real time.

You don’t get that when a streamer dumps an anticipated series all at once midweek.

And that brings me back around to Off Campus, which should be an easy layup for Prime Video.

We’re barely coming down from the high of Heated Rivalry, which wrapped around the holidays and is still fueling conversation. Before that, The Summer I Turned Pretty dominated the cultural landscape to the point that even major brands joined in.

Off Campus is on that same trajectory, right? Wrong! And it has only one thing to blame: the rollout strategy.

What’s puzzling about Prime Video’s decision to release Off Campus all at once is that they know better than anyone that weekly works.

The Summer I Turned Pretty was the crown jewel for the streamer, one of its most successful originals. The final season boosted viewership by nearly 70% and was record-breaking in every respect.

So, why not stick to that formula?

Prime Video has truly set itself apart as a streamer that has cracked the code in the YA genre. It consistently serves a demographic that’s been historically overlooked, tapping into an audience in a way we haven’t really seen since The CW’s peak.

So it’s all the more frustrating when they fail to promote and capitalize on that strength properly.

Is it ignorance or arrogance? It’s truly hard to say.

Off Campus has all the key ingredients to become the next big hit.

The series is set in college, appealing to both Gen Z and female demographics who gravitate toward this kind of escapism.

It’s rooted in romance, which is a genre Prime Video actually embraces while others sideline or disrespect, leaving money on the table in the process.

It’s based on Elle Kennedy’s bestselling series, giving it a built-in fanbase. And it taps into the sports-drama angle, specifically hockey, arriving at the perfect moment after Heated Rivalry.

It also could not be dropping at a more perfect time, as TSITP closed out in early fall before rolling into the global hit Maxton Hall ahead of winter, and now we’ll have another possible hit in the spring.

Not only does it have all of that going for it, but it’s also buoyed by lesser-known stars with a few more established faces, like Steve Howey, attached to it.

The aforementioned other success stories have proven that creating stars is far more appealing than securing the same familiar ones.

Everything about Off Campus should position it as the next big hit. But a binge drop undercuts that potential.

All that anticipation and buildup risks dissipating in a single weekend.

It’s a maddening choice, a true fumble for a series that has everything else going for it.

And sure, that doesn’t mean it can’t succeed.

We Were Liars proved that a new adult adaptation can still find an audience. But it’s hard not to imagine how much more it could have thrived with a weekly rollout that let its twists breathe.

The same argument applies to the late Motorheads. Its “watch it today, forget it tomorrow” quality ultimately led to its demise more than anything else.

The same fate may await the Legally Blonde prequel, Elle, as it debuts over the summer, with all eight episodes releasing at once.

Sure, the binge format is the hallmark of streaming and what distinguishes it from cable and broadcast. But there’s no one-size-fits-all when it comes to series and knowing when to appeal to a demographic.

And Prime Video has stumbled right into a formula that works; so why aren’t they actually using it?

Off Campus still has every chance to connect with viewers.

But if it’s not as successful as it should be, it won’t be because the audiences didn’t show up. It’ll be because the conversation won’t last long enough.

Off Campus’s full eight-episode season premieres Wednesday, May 13.

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.